O.C. Tanner vs. Reward Gateway: Which employee rewards and recognition software is better?

At this point, every company should know employees are its greatest asset, but knowing how to properly recognize and reward them? That’s where things get tricky. Employees today expect more than just a paycheck — they want to feel valued, appreciated, and connected to their workplace. Recognition isn’t just a feel-good initiative; it’s a proven driver of retention, engagement, and productivity.

With so many rewards and recognition platforms available, choosing the right one can feel overwhelming. O.C. Tanner and Reward Gateway each bring their own strengths to the table — but only one platform serves up the full package. When it comes to creating a culture of continuous appreciation and engagement, Achievers doesn’t just rise above the rest — it redefines the game.

In this blog, we’ll break down the strengths and weaknesses of O.C. Tanner and Reward Gateway, compare their key features, and show you why Achievers edges out the competition as the best choice for building a truly engaged workforce. Are you ready? Let’s dive in!

Deep dive: O.C. Tanner

O.C. Tanner has been in the recognition space for decades, establishing itself as a provider of service awards and milestone-based recognition programs. Its reputation is built on traditional recognition, catering to organizations that prioritize long-term service appreciation.

Strengths

• Decades of expertise in employee recognition
• Strong focus on service anniversaries and milestone celebrations
• Hybrid recognition approach, combining physical and digital awards

Weaknesses

• Lower recognition frequency, as the platform prioritizes milestone-based acknowledgments
• Integration challenges, as its legacy technology does not easily support seamless connectivity with modern HR ecosystems
• Limited customization and scalability, making it difficult to tailor the experience to diverse workforce needs

Best for

Organizations with a traditional recognition culture that values service awards over frequent engagement. It is best suited for companies that do not require modern, real-time digital recognition tools but instead seek a structured, milestone-based approach.

Deep dive: Reward Gateway

Reward Gateway provides a user- and budget-friendly recognition platform, making it popular among small to mid-sized businesses. It focuses on perks, wellbeing programs, and simple reward mechanisms, offering a holistic yet basic approach to employee engagement.

Strengths

• Easy-to-use platform, ideal for organizations with minimal training needs
• Emphasis on employee well-being, including perks and discount programs
• Basic reward programs, featuring simple e-cards and instant awards for quick recognition

Weaknesses

• Limited reward variety, as it relies on Amazon-based rewards with fewer global options
• Less scalability for large enterprises, making it challenging to meet the needs of multinational companies
• Lack of advanced integrations, with no certified Workday partnership or robust API options
• Basic analytics and reporting, which do not provide deep insights for HR teams

Best for

Small to mid-sized businesses seeking an affordable and easy-to-deploy recognition solution with a focus on perks and well-being, rather than advanced engagement analytics or seamless integrations.

Comparing key platform features

When comparing these platforms, key differentiators emerge in several categories:

Recognition tools

Recognition is at the heart of any rewards program. O.C. Tanner focuses primarily on milestone-based service awards, making it well-suited for organizations with traditional recognition models. Reward Gateway, on the other hand, provides basic e-cards and instant awards, offering a simple way for managers to acknowledge employees. Achievers stands out with its real-time, peer-to-peer recognition, enabling employees to recognize each other in the moment. Its mobile-first approach ensures that all employees, regardless of location, can participate seamlessly, making it ideal for modern, globally dispersed teams.

Rewards marketplace

A robust rewards marketplace enhances the recognition experience by offering employees meaningful reward options. O.C. Tanner operates a U.S.-centric marketplace with added shipping fees, which can make fulfillment more complex for international employees. Reward Gateway leans on Amazon-based rewards, which provide variety but lack customization and global consistency. Achievers offers a truly global marketplace, spanning over 190+ countries with free shipping, a wide variety of rewards — including merchandise, gift cards, experiences, and donations — and localized fulfillment to provide employees with meaningful options no matter where they are located.

Integration capabilities

Seamless integrations ensure that a recognition platform fits within an organization’s existing HR and productivity ecosystem. O.C. Tanner and Reward Gateway offer some integrations, but they lack the deep connectivity required for streamlined workflows. As a Workday Partner, Achievers provides certified integrations with leading HR systems, an Open API for custom integrations, and membership in the Microsoft Copilot Partner Program ensuring easy and efficient platform connectivity.

Engagement tools

A strong recognition program goes beyond simple rewards — it fosters engagement, too. O.C. Tanner incorporates traditional recognition programs with additional wellbeing tools, while Reward Gateway includes employee communications features. Achievers takes engagement to a higher level, integrating recognition, employee surveys, and real-time sentiment analysis into a single platform. This holistic approach enables organizations to not only recognize employees but also gather valuable feedback and drive meaningful cultural change.

Ease of use

A recognition platform should be intuitive and easy to navigate for both employees and administrators. O.C. Tanner’s system can be complex due to its legacy infrastructure, making it less agile for modern workplaces. Reward Gateway is more straightforward but lacks flexibility in customization. Achievers delivers an intuitive, fully customizable platform that can be branded to match an organization’s corporate identity, ensuring a seamless and engaging user experience that aligns with company culture.

Global reach

For multinational organizations, a recognition platform’s ability to scale globally is essential. O.C. Tanner has a physical presence in multiple regions but relies on separate systems to manage its international programs. Reward Gateway has strong coverage in EMEA and APAC but is weaker in other global regions. Achievers supports employees in 190+ countries, offering localized fulfillment, in-house global marketplace, and multilingual platform support, ensuring consistency and ease of use across international teams.

Analytics capabilities

Data-driven insights help HR teams optimize recognition strategies. O.C. Tanner provides some analytics, but its real-time capabilities are limited. Reward Gateway offers basic reporting features but lacks the depth required for strategic decision-making. Achievers leads in this category with AI-powered analytics, providing organizations with real-time insights, sentiment analysis, and measurable impact tracking to drive engagement and business outcomes.

Achievers: The superior choice

Though O.C. Tanner and Reward Gateway are solid platforms in their own rights, Achievers is the clear choice for companies looking to create a truly engaging and scalable recognition program. Unlike O.C. Tanner’s milestone-based model or Reward Gateway’s basic rewards approach, Achievers delivers a comprehensive, real-time recognition experience designed to keep employees engaged. The Achievers Employee Experience Platform™ provides:

• Real-time, peer-to-peer recognition that encourages continuous appreciation
• A diverse global rewards marketplace, ensuring employees receive meaningful incentives
• Deep integrations with Workday, Microsoft, and other HR systems for seamless implementation
• Advanced analytics and AI-driven insights to measure and improve engagement
• 24/7, award-winning customer support to ensure an exceptional user experience

With a 93% employee adoption rate and a proven impact on retention and productivity, Achievers is the superior choice for organizations that want to go beyond recognition and build a culture of belonging.

The verdict: Why Achievers outshines the competition

While O.C. Tanner and Reward Gateway offer specific strengths, they fall short in providing a modern, scalable, and globally effective recognition experience. Achievers stands apart as the most comprehensive platform, seamlessly integrating recognition, rewards, and engagement analytics to create a culture of belonging.

Achievers’ superior technology, vast global rewards marketplace, and deep integration capabilities make it the best choice for organizations looking to elevate their employee experience. Unlike O.C. Tanner, which remains focused on legacy milestone-based programs, and Reward Gateway, which lacks scalability for large enterprises, Achievers delivers a seamless, modern approach to recognition and employee engagement.

Companies that prioritize real-time recognition, meaningful rewards, and data-driven engagement will find Achievers to be the most effective solution. The platform’s AI-driven analytics ensure that recognition efforts lead to measurable outcomes, boosting morale and productivity across diverse, global teams.

The choice is clear: modern, scalable recognition with Achievers, or settling for less. Your employees know what they want — do you?

Achievers offers employee recognition tools catered to your company’s unique needs

Discover employee recognition at its best

Take your workplace to the next level

Book a demo now