O.C. Tanner vs. Reward Gateway: Which employee rewards and recognition software is better?

By now, every company knows their greatest asset is their people. But knowing how to recognize and reward them effectively? That’s where things get tricky. Employees expect more than just a paycheck — they want to feel valued, appreciated, and connected to their workplace. Recognition isn’t just a feel-good initiative; it’s a proven driver of retention, engagement, and performance.

With so many employee recognition platforms out there, choosing the right one can feel overwhelming. O.C. Tanner and Reward Gateway each bring unique strengths — but only one platform delivers the full package. When it comes to building a culture of continuous appreciation and deep engagement, Achievers doesn’t just rise above — it redefines what’s possible.

In this blog, we’ll break down the strengths and weaknesses of O.C. Tanner and Reward Gateway, compare their key features, and explain why Achievers is the most complete, scalable, and future-ready platform for organizations serious about employee experience.

Deep dive: O.C. Tanner

O.C. Tanner has been in the recognition space for decades, establishing itself as a provider of service awards and milestone-based recognition programs. Its legacy approach focuses on traditional recognition — celebrating long-term tenure and notable milestones.

Pros

• Decades of expertise in employee recognition
• Strong focus on service anniversaries and milestone celebrations
• Hybrid recognition approach, combining physical and digital awards

Cons

• Lower recognition frequency, as the platform prioritizes milestone-based acknowledgments
• Integration challenges, as its legacy technology does not easily support seamless connectivity with modern HR ecosystems
• Limited customization and scalability, making it difficult to tailor the experience to diverse workforce needs

Best for

Organizations with a traditional recognition culture that values service awards over frequent engagement. It is best suited for companies that do not require modern, real-time digital recognition tools but instead seek a structured, milestone-based approach.

Deep dive: Reward Gateway

Reward Gateway positions itself as a user-friendly, budget-conscious recognition platform, particularly popular among small to mid-sized businesses. Its offerings center around perks, wellbeing resources, and simple reward mechanics — delivering a broad, yet surface-level approach to employee engagement.

Pros

• Easy-to-use platform, ideal for organizations with minimal training needs
• Emphasis on employee well-being, including perks and discount programs
• Basic reward programs, featuring simple e-cards and instant awards for quick recognition

Cons

• Limited reward variety, as it relies on Amazon-based rewards with fewer global options
• Less scalability for large enterprises, making it challenging to meet the needs of multinational companies
• Lack of advanced integrations, with no certified Workday partnership or robust API options
• Basic analytics and reporting, which do not provide deep insights for HR teams

Best for

Small to mid-sized businesses seeking an affordable and easy-to-deploy recognition solution with a focus on perks and well-being, rather than advanced engagement analytics or seamless integrations.

Feature-by-feature comparison

When comparing these platforms, key differentiators emerge in several categories:

Recognition tools

Recognition is central to any rewards program. O.C. Tanner focuses on milestone-based service awards, suiting traditional models. Reward Gateway offers basic e-cards and instant awards for quick, manager-led recognition. Achievers stands out with real-time, peer-to-peer recognition and a mobile-first design that enables seamless participation across locations — making it a strong fit for modern, global teams that value frequent, inclusive recognition.

Rewards marketplace

A robust rewards marketplace enhances the recognition experience by offering meaningful, flexible options. O.C. Tanner’s U.S.-centric marketplace includes added shipping fees, complicating fulfillment for international employees. Reward Gateway leans on Amazon-based rewards, offering variety but limited customization and inconsistent global coverage. Achievers offers a truly global marketplace across 190+ countries with free shipping, localized fulfillment, and a wide range of options—including merchandise, gift cards, experiences, and donations—ensuring employees everywhere receive relevant, meaningful rewards without added hassle.

Integration capabilities

Seamless integrations ensure that a recognition platform fits within an organization’s existing HR and productivity ecosystem. O.C. Tanner and Reward Gateway offer some integrations, but they lack the deep connectivity required for streamlined workflows. As a Workday Partner, Achievers provides certified integrations with leading HR systems, an Open API for custom integrations, and membership in the Microsoft Copilot Partner Program, ensuring easy and efficient platform connectivity.

Engagement tools

A strong recognition program goes beyond simple rewards — it fosters engagement, too. O.C. Tanner incorporates traditional recognition programs with additional well-being tools, while Reward Gateway includes employee communications features. Achievers takes engagement further by integrating recognition, employee surveys, and real-time sentiment analysis in one platform. This unified approach enables organizations to recognize great work, gather feedback, and take action — all in one continuous loop.

Ease of use

A recognition platform should be intuitive and easy to navigate for both employees and administrators. O.C. Tanner’s system can be complex due to its legacy infrastructure, making it less agile for modern workplaces. Reward Gateway is more straightforward but lacks flexibility in customization. Achievers delivers an intuitive, fully customizable platform that can be branded to match an organization’s corporate identity, ensuring a seamless and engaging user experience that aligns with company culture.

Global reach

For multinational organizations, a recognition platform’s ability to scale globally is essential. O.C. Tanner has a physical presence in multiple regions but relies on separate systems to manage its international programs. Reward Gateway has strong coverage in EMEA and APAC but is weaker in other global regions. Achievers, on the other hand, supports employees in 190+ countries, offering localized fulfillment, an in-house global marketplace, and multilingual platform support, ensuring consistency and ease of use across international teams.

Analytics capabilities

To optimize your recognition strategy, you need more than just basic reports. O.C. Tanner offers limited real-time analytics, and Reward Gateway’s reporting lacks strategic depth. Achievers leads with AI-powered analytics, providing real-time insights, sentiment tracking, and impact measurement to help organizations understand what’s working and continuously improve their culture.

Achievers: The superior choice

While O.C. Tanner and Reward Gateway offer niche strengths, Achievers is the clear choice for companies that want to build a recognition program that drives measurable results and scales globally.

Unlike milestone-based or perks-focused models, Achievers delivers a modern, continuous recognition experience that fuels engagement and connection across your workforce. Achievers’ employee engagement platform provides:

• Real-time, peer-to-peer recognition: Employees can recognize each other instantly, fostering continuous appreciation and engagement.
• Global rewards marketplace: Achievers offers a wide range of reward options tailored to employees’ diverse preferences, motivating and inspiring teams worldwide.
• Seamless HR integrations: Deep integrations with Workday, Microsoft, and other HR systems for seamless implementation.
• Analytics and AI insights: Organizations can track engagement and measure the impact of recognition programs with data-driven insights.
• 24/7 customer support: Award-winning customer support to ensure an exceptional user experience.

With a 93% employee adoption rate and a proven impact on retention and productivity, Achievers is the superior choice for organizations that want to go beyond recognition and build a culture of belonging.

Which platform is right for you?

Selecting the right employee rewards and recognition platform is a decision that shapes company culture, engagement, and long-term success. O.C. Tanner, Reward Gateway, and Achievers each bring unique strengths to the table — but their fit depends on your organization’s needs and ambitions.

O.C. Tanner

O.C. Tanner is a strong choice for organizations that value tradition and symbolic recognition. Known for service awards and milestone celebrations, its programs are rooted in commemorating long-term contributions. Companies that want to emphasize legacy, loyalty, and formal recognition moments may find O.C. Tanner aligns with their priorities.

Reward Gateway

Reward Gateway caters to organizations looking for a broad toolkit that combines employee recognition with perks, discounts, and communication features. Its platform appeals to companies aiming for a one-stop shop approach, especially when employee discounts and benefits sit high on the priority list. For cost-conscious businesses, Reward Gateway can be a practical option.

Achievers: Driving lasting engagement

For organizations that want more than symbolic recognition or discount-driven rewards, Achievers is the standout choice. Designed to embed recognition into daily workflows, Achievers doesn’t just celebrate contributions — it actively drives culture change and alignment with business goals. By tying recognition to core values, it creates a unified, purpose-driven workforce where every acknowledgment fuels engagement, innovation, and performance.

Achievers is the best all-around platform for companies that want recognition to be more than a program — but rather a strategic driver of culture, connection, and measurable results.

The verdict: Why Achievers outshines the competition

While O.C. Tanner and Reward Gateway have their strengths, they don’t offer the modern, scalable, and globally effective recognition experience organizations need today.

Achievers stands apart, integrating recognition, rewards, and engagement analytics to build a culture of belonging. Its advanced technology, expansive global rewards marketplace, and deep integration capabilities make it ideal for companies seeking to elevate the employee experience.

Unlike O.C. Tanner’s legacy milestone-focused programs or Reward Gateway’s limited scalability, Achievers delivers real-time recognition, meaningful rewards, and data-driven insights that boost morale, productivity, and engagement across global teams.

The choice is clear: modern, scalable recognition with Achievers — or settling for less. Your employees know what they want — do you?

Want employee recognition tools catered to your company’s unique needs?

Explore Achievers Recognize™

Make the switch to Achievers with confidence

Download the switchers guide